When do I use "Shall" and when do I use "Will"?

"Will" = general future for all persons (everyday use). "Shall" = formal suggestions ("Shall we?"), legal obligations in contracts, and archaic English with I/we.

What is the most common mistake with "Shall" and "Will"?

The most common error: not knowing that "shall" is used in formal English for suggestions ("Shall we go?"). The second: confusing them in contracts, where "shall" expresses legal obligation and is not interchangeable with "will."

Resources

Lecciones de gramática Lecturas Ejercicios de listening Flash cards Falsos amigos ¿Cuál usar?Sufijos Prefijos

Discover your level Blog

ESEN

Which one to use?Intermediateverbo modalverbo modal

ShallvsWill

'Shall' is a formal modal for first person or legal contexts; 'will' is the general future for all persons in modern English.

Side-by-side comparison

Shall

verbo modal

"Will" is the standard form for talking about the future in all contexts and persons. It is the one used in everyday English everywhere.

Shall we take a break? We have been working for three hours straight.
The contract states that the contractor shall complete all work before the agreed deadline.
Shall I open the window? It is getting warm in here.

Will

verbo modal

"Shall" is mainly used in British English with "I" and "we" for the future, and in questions to make suggestions or offer help: "Shall we go?"

I will send you the updated report as soon as the team finishes reviewing it.
The new policy will take effect on the first of next month, all employees will be notified by email.
Will you be joining us for the team dinner on Friday, or do you have other plans?

Common mistake

•The most common error: not knowing that "shall" is used in formal English for suggestions ("Shall we go?").
•The second: confusing them in contracts, where "shall" expresses legal obligation and is not interchangeable with "will."

Trick to remember it

When do you use SHALL in modern English? Only 2 cases: "Shall we...?" (formal suggestion), and legal contracts ("Payment shall be due..."). Outside those 2, WILL — always, no exception.

Quick rule

•"Will" = general future for all persons (everyday use).
•"Shall" = formal suggestions ("Shall we?"), legal obligations in contracts, and archaic English with I/we.

Did you know?

In classic nineteenth-century British English, there was a very precise rule: SHALL with I/we expressed neutral simple future; WILL with I/we expressed strong will or determination. "I shall drown, nobody will save me!" meant "I will drown, nobody will save me" (no intention involved). "I will drown, nobody shall save me!" meant "I intend to drown, and I forbid anyone to save me." This distinction was so subtle that George Bernard Shaw satirized it: he said only the English understood the difference, and even among themselves there was disagreement. Today the distinction has nearly disappeared from American English, surviving only in formal British English and legal language.